New Book Reveals True Story of the American Pope Nobody Expected

American Pontiff Tells
Pope Leo XIV’s True Mission

History changed on May 8, 2025.

White smoke rose from the Sistine Chapel. The crowds in St. Peter’s Square waited in breathless anticipation.

When the name was announced—Robert Francis Prevost, Pope Leo XIV — the world was stunned.

For the first time in two thousand years, an American had become the Bishop of Rome, the spiritual leader of 1.4 billion Catholics worldwide.

But who was this man?

He was a Cardinal for just over a year. Why did the cardinals choose him?

And what does his leadership mean for the future of the Roman Catholic Church?

In American Pontiff: Pope Leo XIV and His Plan to Heal the Church, bestselling author and historian Paul Kengor, PhD delivers the first definitive biography of the first American pope.

Kengor unveils the dramatic story behind his election, his extraordinary life journey, and his bold vision for restoring unity to a Church shaken by crisis and division.

Drawing on insider accounts, Vatican sources, and deep historical insight, this compelling book pulls readers inside one of the most consequential moments in modern religious history.

Shocking Conclave That Changed the Church

Few observers expected the outcome.

Leading papal candidates included powerful cardinals from Italy, Asia, Africa, and Europe.

Analysts predicted a long and divisive conclave.

Most of the Cardinals had never met each other before because the late Pope Francis had rarely called meetings.

And their proceedings are shrouded in secrecy.

But Kengor, for the first time, reveals how the Conclave unfolded. The early votes. The angry debates.

And then the decisive decision in favor of Prevost.

It was like a Hollywood movie — a most dramatic surprise as the cardinals presumed winner Cardinal Parolin was jettisoned.

The movement for Prevost started with a small number and then grew as each ballot was counted.

The Princes of the Church rallied around a little-known American missionary bishop who had spent decades far from America and the spotlight.

Within just four rounds of voting, the Church had a new and surprising leader.

Who Is Pope Leo XIV

The decision stunned the world — and this book explains why it happened and the man who became pope.

Kengor reveals the intense and secret debates among cardinals, the factions inside the Vatican, and the urgent search for a leader who could bring clarity and stability after years of turmoil.

The Church was in crisis: spiritually, politically and financially. The Vatican itself owed billions in pensions and bills.

The conclave was not merely a political contest — it was a moment of historic reckoning for the Catholic Church. It was a moment to save the church.

From Chicago to the Chair of St. Peter

At the heart of the story is a remarkable man.

Born in Chicago, Robert Francis Prevost grew up in a humble Midwestern family.

Few could have imagined that the altar boy from Illinois would someday stand on the balcony of St. Peter’s Basilica as pope.

Prevost himself seemed shocked as tens of thousands of Italians and others cheered his arrival.

• His early vocation and formation in the Augustinian order
• His missionary work in Peru, where he spent decades serving the poor
• His rise from parish priest to bishop and eventually cardinal
• His reputation as a quiet bridge-builder respected across ideological divides

Prevost’s unique international background helped make him something rare in the Church hierarchy: an American who was not seen as “too American.”

By the time of the conclave, many cardinals viewed him as the ideal compromise candidate — someone capable of healing a fractured Church.

Inside the Turbulent Francis Era

To understand Leo XIV’s mission, one must first understand the chaos he inherited.

One of the book’s most revealing sections examines the controversial pontificate of Pope Francis, whose leadership sparked fierce debate across the Catholic world.

Kengor explores:

• The theological conflicts and internal divisions that marked Francis’s years
• The clashes between traditionalists and reformers over everything from the Latin Mass to gay marriage.
• The Vatican’s controversial agreements with Communist China
• The disputes over liturgy, doctrine, and Church governance
• Francis’ decision to approve of gay union blessings — a decision that shocked even his own Cardinal appointees
• The growing frustration among bishops and cardinals over confusion within the Church

By the time Francis died in April 2025, many cardinals agreed on one thing: the Church desperately needed unity, clarity, and stability.

And they wanted an “un-Francis” — a candidate who would unite, heal and remain faithful to the catechism of the faith.

The conclave that followed would determine whether the Church continued on its dangerous path — or charted a new course.

The Powerful Legacy of the Papacy

Beyond modern politics and Vatican intrigue, American Pontiff also takes readers deep into the sweeping history of the papacy itself.

Kengor connects the election of Leo XIV to a lineage stretching back two millennia — beginning with St. Peter, the fisherman crucified under Emperor Nero.

The book recounts dramatic episodes from Church history, including:

• The persecution of early Christians in ancient Rome
• The courageous stand of St. Catherine of Siena, who persuaded a reluctant pope to return to Rome
• The discovery of the tomb and bones of St. Peter beneath the Vatican in the twentieth century
• The resilience of the papacy through wars, revolutions, and political upheavals

These stories remind readers that the office of the pope has survived extraordinary challenges for nearly 2,000 years.

Leo XIV now becomes the newest steward of that legacy.

A Church at a Crossroads

Perhaps the most important question the book addresses is this: What kind of pope will Leo XIV be?

Kengor explores the themes that define the new pontiff’s vision:

• Healing Division
  After years of theological disputes and political polarization within Catholicism, Leo XIV has pledged to restore unity across the global Church.
• Restoring Clarity
  Many cardinals sought a leader who could bring doctrinal clarity to debates over faith, morality, and Church teaching.
• Bridging Cultures
  As both an American and a missionary shaped by Latin America, Leo XIV embodies a rare blend of cultures that may help him lead a truly global Church.
• Confronting Modern Challenges
  From secularization to political conflict, the Catholic Church faces enormous pressures in the twenty-first century. Leo XIV must guide the Church through these storms while preserving its timeless mission.

A Cast of Influential Figures

The book also introduces readers to the powerful personalities who shaped the drama of the papal transition.

Among them:

• The late Pope Francis, whose controversial leadership set the stage for the historic conclave
• Cardinal Pietro Parolin, the Vatican diplomat considered the early favorite for the papacy but infuriated many with his secret deal with communist China
• Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle, a charismatic Filipino church leader widely admired across the Catholic world
• Cardinal Raymond Burke, a leading voice among traditionalist Catholics who had crossed swords with Francis
• Cardinal Blase Cupich, the pro-Francis Chicago Archbishop who mentored and promoted Leo
• Other influential American church leaders

Through these figures, Kengor reveals the complex alliances and tensions that influence the Church at its highest levels.

Why This Book Matters

The election of Pope Leo XIV is not just a Catholic story — it is a global one.

The papacy remains one of the most influential institutions in human history, shaping politics, culture, ethics, and international diplomacy.

This book helps readers understand:

• Why the election of an American pope shocked the world
• The impact President Trump is having on the Church in the US and globally
• How Vatican politics actually works
• What the future may hold for the Catholic Church
• Why Leo XIV could become one of the most consequential religious leaders of the twenty-first century

Whether you are Catholic, a believing Christian or simply fascinated by world and Vatican affairs, you need to read American Pontiff and the extraordinary window it offers into a moment that may reshape the future of Christianity.

Definitive Biography of a Historic Pope

About the Author

Paul Kengor, Ph.D., is the New York Times bestselling author of God and Ronald Reagan: A Spiritual Life, The Crusader: Ronald Reagan and the Fall of Communism and A Pope and a President: John Paul II, Ronald Reagan. A renowned historian few know the inner workings of the Church and American politics like Kengor. Editor of The American Spectator, he serves as executive director at the Institute for Faith & Freedom as well as a visiting fellow at Stanford’s Hoover Institution. A professor at Grove City College, Dr. Kengor is one of America’s leading experts on the presidency, faith, the Cold War, communism, and Catholic history.

Written by New York Times bestselling author Paul Kengor, one of America’s most respected historians of religion and politics, American Pontiff combines rigorous scholarship with gripping storytelling.

The result is a book that reads like a political thriller — but tells a true story unfolding at the very heart of the Vatican.

It is the first comprehensive account of the life, election, and vision of Pope Leo XIV.

And it is essential reading for anyone who wants to understand the future of the Catholic Church — and the remarkable American who now leads it.

Get your copy of American Pontiff: Pope Leo XIV and His Plan to Heal the Church today — and discover the inside story of the first American pope.

PLUS TWO FREE GIFTS:
That Will Inspire and Deepen Your Faith

To complement American Pontiff, you’ll also receive two extraordinary books — powerful spiritual works that uplift, encourage, and enrich your understanding of prayer, faith, leadership, and the Church’s role in the modern world.

BONUS Gift #1:
Six Popes: A Son of the Church Remembers

This captivating memoir by Monsignor Hilary C. Franco offers a rare firsthand look inside the heart of the Catholic Church during some of the most consequential decades in history.

Born in the Bronx to a humble immigrant family, Franco rose to serve the Church at the highest levels — working with global leaders, attending historic Vatican Councils, and serving under six pontiffs: John XXIII, Paul VI, John Paul I, John Paul II, Benedict XVI, and Pope Francis.

Cardinal Timothy Dolan praises Franco as an “engaging storyteller,” and this memoir proves why. Inspiring, wise, and historically rich, Six Popes is a faith-filled journey through the spiritual and cultural events that shaped our world.

BONUS Gift #2:
How to Pray & How to Study the Bible

For nearly 100 years, believers around the world have turned to R. A. Torrey’s How to Pray as the essential guide to a deeper prayer life.

Featuring a heartfelt foreword by Gov. Mike Huckabee, who calls it “a book every believer should read”, this special edition also includes Torrey’s companion guide, How to Study the Bible for Greatest Profit.

Together, these two works help you draw closer to God, understand His Word more deeply, and strengthen your daily walk of faith.

Why Newsmax Magazine?

Newsmax Magazine is the one source that brings you in-depth cover stories, unvarnished truth you deserve, and hard hitting investigative reports that you can’t find in mainstream media outlets.

It’s the magazine that’s been praised by President Donald J. Trump, Dr. Ben Carson, and countless others.

Inside every issue, you’ll read powerful commentary from trusted voices like Bill O’Reilly, Ben Stein, Dr. Laura, Nancy Brinker, and many more.

Even the mainstream media can’t ignore it. Newsmax Magazine is regularly cited by Meet the Press, CNN, Fox News, MSNBC, The New York Times, and more.

In today’s fast-changing and unpredictable world, you deserve reporting that doesn’t flinch, doesn’t filter, and doesn’t follow the herd.

As Ben Stein says, Newsmax Magazine delivers “the bare-knuckles truth”, giving you the insight you need to protect your family, your freedom, and your future.

Find out why close to a million Americans read Newsmax Magazine each month . . .  and why patriots everywhere are saying, “Finally — a magazine that tells it like it is.”

Get Your FREE Books
With This Special Offer!

 

YES! Rush me my FREE copy of American Pontiff with my selection below:

IMPORTANT NOTE: Sales tax included where applicable. Your subscription comes with a convenient automatic renewal. At the end of your subscription, we will notify you. If you want to keep the publication, do nothing and we will renew your subscription using your credit/debit card on file and charge you the lowest renewal rate then in effect for one year (12 issues) of Newsmax Magazine. And then every year thereafter at the lowest renewal rates then in effect. There is no risk, you can cancel at any time for a refund of the unused portion of your subscription.